Typically narcissistic blogging.

Race in The Hunger Games

So there was a minor uproar, recently, when post-racial America flipped the fuck out over the fact that Rue and Cinna were OMG BLACK. I am positively fascinated that this was an issue. Well. I’m negatively fascinated. Oh, and horrified.

As most of the literate world has figured out, if you read The Hunger Games, Rue and Thresh were described as having dark skin and hair, and Cinna wasn’t described at all, apart from his makeup.

And yet, somehow, the fact that Rue, one of my favorite characters, was oh-so-suddenly Black, ruined the movie for people. Despite the fact that Amandla Stenberg is a stunning little actor, who took what little of her character the filmmakers thought to include in the film and still managed to make me adore her. Despite the fact that watching a child die, brutally murdered by another kid so that the evil wealthy folk might keep their fancy, frivolous boots on the necks of the twelve districts should be heartbreaking regardless of her race. I cried when I watched Rue die. And it had nothing to do with her race, and everything to do with the fact that she was wonderful, lovable, and fucking tragic. Even Katniss, for all that she has the social aptitude and compassion of your average turnip, figured that out.

To be perfectly honest, my primary concern was not that Rue is Black. It’s that both Black tributes come from the same district, which hints at segregation (I know, the film showed District 11 and there were White people there, but it wasn’t that clear in the book, and I really wonder how much of a conscious choice that was). But that’s neither here nor there for this particular discussion.

As for Cinna, he could have been any race at all, so the choice of Lenny Kravitz for such a wonderfully sympathetic and essential character must have been positively devastating for the bigots who defaulted to White in their limited imaginations.

America, what the fuck. This is just gross.

Look, I don’t have scales over my eyes about the racism that is rampant in this country. I am not surprised by this. But that doesn’t stop me from being disappointed. It doesn’t stop me from being disgusted. And while I am not saying anything new or deep in this post, I still have to say it. In the wake of the murder of Trayvon Martin, in the wake of the attempts to free Zimmerman of blame, in the wake of tweets complaining that a character in a movie was Black (and that one tweet from the individual who was less affected by Rue’s death because of the color of her skin), in the wake of those godawful “Don’t Re-Nig bumper stickers, being speechlessly horrified feels a lot like silence.

And silence, in the wake of these things, won’t do.

3 responses

  1. Fuck, i totally agree! I LOVE the Hunger Games books, and seeing all this happen devastates me. People also have to realise that Panem was once the USA, and who lives in the USA too? Black people.

    April 1, 2012 at 9:42 pm

  2. Cat

    I have read the books but not seen the movie yet, fwiw I imagined Cinna as somehow like Ruby Rhod from the 5th element, who happens to be black. And from the books I pictured Rue as Latino or Native American, tho never gave it much thought.
    Looks like people’s bigotry goes as far as subconsciously overriding what is described in a book… sucks to be in their heads in so many ways.

    April 1, 2012 at 11:20 pm

  3. rmharman

    Yeah, there were links from somebody on one of the Slate blogs (DoubleX, I think, given what the links were to) over to Jezebel and Feministe talking about these issues. Reading them was kind of horrifying. I mean, I know intellectually that these troglodytes are out there, but HOLY F***ING S**T. Do they really not know how unbelievably awful they are? How embarrassed they ought to be to publicly display the filthy festering cesspools that they apparently have where they ought to have a human soul?

    One encouraging thing about the whole affair was that I found it interesting how thoroughly this discussion spread through the liberal blogosphere. This has been an ongoing trend over the last decade, but it seems like the various liberal “interest groups” have finally developed a united approach to civil rights and respect for all citizens. So you see active discussion of racial hatred on blogs that are in theory “about” gender.

    April 2, 2012 at 10:33 am

Talk back to me:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s